Drupal Schools Network

Drupal Schools Network - A mutually supporting learning community.
Home › Drupal Schools Network Blog

Don't Trust eSchoolNews.com

This may be obvious, but I'll say it anyway.

I just looked through the "Special Report" of the January issue of eSchoolNews, and even though I am a proponent of technology integration, I felt disgust at the industrial pandering and begged questions. Example:

"Kids have to power down as they walk into a school. They have to turn off the technology they use and go back to a traditional lecture environment. No wonder kids are bored and disengaged....  Yet it is difficult to get educators and school leaders to tackle the problem, because of the existing school system infrastructure."

Of course, students like to choose the things they attend to and participate in! When was that not true?

Unless the school has become a prison, every classroom teacher has the chance to create an environment where students will "buy in" and act as if their participation was a choice rather than a compulsion.

It's true that you can bribe students with computers to make that choice.  Who wouldn't prefer to be in a computer lab than a lecture hall, all other things equal?

But eSchool News promotes the reliance upon technology to cure the problem of student disengagement, as if the lack of technology caused the problem.  It is painful to imagine teachers and administrators so uncritical as to read along head-nodding, but no doubt people do.

Good teachers establish relationships with their classes that result in "suspension of resistance."   They are able to negotiate a social contract with their classes as social groups, so when they say "we," students hear "us," not  "you".  

What does this have to do with Drupal?

The social networking environment of Drupal empowers students and teachers to interact more freely than in the classroom.  Shy students may lead online discussions, though they might never be caught walking to the front of a classroom and holding forth for 10 minutes.

This empowerment only makes sense in the hands of a teacher who has assumed and been granted social leadership by her students, it seems to me.

When such a teacher asks her students to go home to post and comment online,  they are likely to do so with personal intent, and thus contribute to shared meaning and enthusiasm online and later in the classroom.

What else would sustain the willingness of teenagers to give more attention to school assignments than to 15 IM buddies messaging them?

-Bram

 

Please login or register to sign up for this Blog entry.
  • Teaching and Learning
  • Learning 2.0
  • Login or register to post comments

Motives of 21st-Century-Skills Advocates Questioned

admin — Mon, 02/01/2010 - 11:30
Not just eSchoolNews! But Education Week is much more trustworthy as a source. Here's a recent article (12/9/09) about the business of selling technology as a core skill, and how good or bad that might be: http://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2009/12/09/14partnership_ep.h29.html
  • Login or register to post comments

Drupal Schools

Add yours!

  • Catlin Gabel School
  • Menomonie School District
  • Batavia Public Schools (Illinois)
  • Sunnyside Unified School District (Tucscon, AZ)
  • Bainbridge Island School District (WA)
  •  
  • 1 of 2
  • ››
more
Syndicate content

Random FAQs

  • How do you automate page creation for new teachers & students?
  • How can you tell if a site is made with Drupal?
  • Should I use a Classroom Blog or Weekly Newsletter?
  • What Modules do I use to create a Staff Directory?
  • Why Create Drupal Learning Modules when there is Moodle?
All FAQs

Teaching Ideas

Add an Idea!

  • Use ProsePoint for a Newsletter about a Curriculum Topic
  • Using Screencasting (e.g. Skype) to engage and build community with online learners
more
Syndicate content

Search

Drupal Ed Resources

Suggest one!

  • 101 Lectures for Open Source in Education
  • Drupal Schools to add to the Registry
  • Introduction to Social Media Learning Guide
  • Online facilitation: Facilitating, moderating, or teaching?
  • A Portal to Media Literacy
  •  
  • 1 of 7
  • ››
more
Syndicate content

Recent blog posts

  • Case Study Presentation at Design 4 Drupal, MIT
  • Buckminster Fuller's Drupal Site
  • Students! Lets Support Drupal In Our Schools - here.
  • EduCon 2.2: "Learning 2.0"
  • Learning Circles for Learning 2.0 Chops
  • Don't Trust eSchoolNews.com
  • Dries' Vision for Drupal - a School Restructuring Model?
  • The Steep "Unlearning Curve"
  • What is Drupal best at, and how can K-12 schools best use it?
more

Account Information: Full Name
Bram Moreinis's picture
Bram Moreinis Springs Public School
kassissieh's picture
Richard Kassissieh Catlin Gabel School
gusaus's picture
Gus Austin Drupal Kata
mathieso's picture
Kieran Mathieson Oakland University
Kyle Mathews's picture
Kyle Mathews Brigham Young University
more

User login

4 + 10 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.
  • Create new account
  • Request new password

We hereby reach out to educators in the Drupal community and Drupalers in the education community for help in envisioning and building this site.

Bram Moreinis, Principal
Hudson Valley Tech Scouts


Game Face Web Design supports and hosts this site as an open resource: no fees, and no self-promotion.

Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

Drupal Schools Network is a project of the Hudson Valley Tech Scouts and other partners.